College Cancels ‘Vagina Monologues’ To Avoid Excluding Women Who Don’t Have Them

When Eve Ensler penned her play in 1996, she was celebrating the vagina and women’s sexuality. It was shocking. But it seems the play is no longer shocking. Now it is not inclusive enough!
By Nicky Fernandes from Hiroshima, Japan (Vagina Monologues Poster.jpg) via Wikimedia CommonsStudent Erin Murphy explained in the Campus Reform:“…at its core, the show offers an extremely narrow perspective on what it means to be a woman …”

“Gender is a wide and varied experience, one that cannot simply be reduced to biological or anatomical distinctions, and many of us who have participated in the show have grown increasingly uncomfortable presenting material that is inherently reductionist and exclusive.”

 A fundraiser named itself, “A Night Of A Thousand Vaginas.” The people who opposed it felt it was hurtful to those who didn’t have a vagina.

Who doesn’t have a vagina? Well, men, of course. The group also includes women who have had a hysterectomy and women born without a vagina – it happens. I knew one man who was born with a vagina. He had to get annual pap smears just like the rest of us.

Yet there is another group I had not considered – some of the transgender individuals. Here is how that happens. A trans individual lives fully as a woman, and she has not had the genital reconstructive surgery.

But the argument that the play is blatantly transphobic is flawed. Sure, some women and self-identifying women donot have vaginas. That does not invalidate The Vagina Monologues.

The far greater majority of women have a vagina. So, The Vagina Monologues traditional show is valid.

Death Of A Salesman is dated, yet it has many universal aspects. Plays cannot be all things to all people, and that does not make The Vagina Monologues transphobic.

My concern is that in an attempt to be all-inclusive, we women fall into the trap of furthering misogyny.

This is an era where the farthest right wing people blush when they hear the word “vagina.” I’m not sure they can pronounce it, because I don’t believe I’ve ever heard them say it.

So let’s hear it for vaginas – loudly and often!

 

Like Gloria Christie’s Facebook page, visit her website, and follow her on Twitter. Click here to buy Gloria Christie a hot cup of Mocha Coffee.

____________________________________________

NOTE: This article was originally published on LiberalAmerica.org

About Gloria Christie

 Gloria Christie founded Gloria Christie Reports, a common sense column about liberal politics. She wrote for Addictinginfo.org, the Kansas City Star, Where High Technology Meets Politics for London’s IDG-Connect Blog and The Best Times. Her total readership is over 5 million. Christie has an MS in radio-TV-film and an MPA in business/government relations. She was a systemic problems consulting expert for Fortune 100/500 businesses here and off-shore. Christie invented and implemented the first computerized patient chart. She also worked on Howard Dean’s, John Kerry’s, and Barak Obama’s presidential campaigns. She is particularly interested in liberal politics, high-tech, complex systems, and change.

Advertisements